i want to come back becase i love you all, bt can you help me to understand these qestions? i need help understanding before i can dedicate my life again avenue might work. i'm being naive, but it just might in certain circumstances.
I don't know if I'd be able to use my own belief system as "bait", when I KNOW I'd NEVER go back; you'd be lying to her by suggesting that is even a possibility.... That merely reinforces her own faith.
if i'm honest i have a fair bit of denial going on. i've stopped going to meetings for a long time, but i never called it a cult until a couple years ago. in fact, i'd have said that the jehovah's witnesses were weird, that they were wrong, but not really any different than other christians and that's not true.
the jehovah's witnesses are a cult. my mom is in a cult. i was raised in a cult.
From a logical standpoint, you need to realize that saying "JWs are a cult" IS a conclusion, one that takes months, if not years, of evidence to build to support the claim (and the evidence IS out there).
I am always tempted to repeat MY truth (my conclusion), and expect others to accept it on MY word, but think about it: what good would THAT do? JWs have accepted conclusions without supportive evidence for YEARS, and I'd prefer they learn to be skeptical THINKERS, and not simply accept MY or anyone else's conclusion, EVEN IF IT IS CORRECT. That blind acceptance is exactly how they ended up in a cult.
This is an occasion where less really is more. Telling her everything will accomplish nothing.
I think that's a doubtful assertion, where "one size doesn't fit all".
My brother was a Bethelite, pioneer, etc and when he "awoke" he was the kind where an appeal to logic and facts worked on him; he saw the errors with the Bible, and lost ALL Xian religion in one fell swoop.
Others (such as Ray Franz) lost their flavor of religion, but didn't become atheists (like me). Problem is, these types may then go to another flavor of the same lie, and spend many years denying facts (out of frying pan into fire). It's a bit like pulling a band-aid: do you prefer a less-intense drawn-out experience, or a sharper, but quicker process?
My bottom line is I cannot worry about whatever results from people learning the real TRUTH: I didn't tell them the LIE in the first place, and my job is not to shelter others from themselves or become the relected target of their hatred, but to provide the knowledge needed for them to be able to make an informed decision.
I know, I'm a bit of a maverick, placing truth above all else... Not unusual for ex-JWs to be like that, since we've spent years telling others we HAVE truths (and the irony is, sometimes there are no "one size fits all" truths).
PS here's the difficult thing for YOU to comtemplate: you need to tease out WHY you feel the need to act. Don't say it here (it's none of OUR business), but ask yourself what drives you to want to do this. Is it your own ego speaking, or to prove to her that you are right, or to make her share in your pain? REM wrote a song about "Losing My Religion", and while it's ultimately a worthy goal (IMO), it's also a painful process to go thru.